Using small cities to understand the crowd behind OpenStreetMap
نویسنده
چکیده
As businesses and governments integrate OpenStreetMap (OSM) into their services in ways that require comprehensive coverage, there is a need to expand research outside of major urban areas and consider the strength of the map in smaller cities. A place-specific inquiry into the OSM contributor sets in small cities allows an intimate look at user motives, locations, and editing habits that are readily described in the OSM metadata and user profile pages, but often missed by aggregate studies of OSM data. Using quantitative and qualitative evidence from the OSM history of five small cities across North and South America, I show that OSM is not accumulating large local corpuses of editors outside of major urban areas. In these more remote places OSM remains largely at the mercy of an unpredictable mix of casual contributions, business interests, feature-specific "hobbyists", bots, and importers, all passing through the map at different scales for different reasons. I present a typology of roles played by contributors as they expand and fix OSM in casual, systematic, and automated fashion. I argue that these roles are too complex to be conceptualized with the traditional "citizen as sensor" model of understanding volunteered geographic information. While some contributors are driven by pride of place, others are more interested in improving map quality or ensuring certain feature types are represented. Institutions considering the use of OSM data in their projects should be aware of these varied influences and their potential effects on the data.
منابع مشابه
Using Crowd-Sourced Data to Quantify the Complex Urban Fabric - OpenStreetMap and the Urban-Rural Index
متن کامل
Practical simulation of virtual crowds using points of interest
Article history: Received 23 May 2015 Received in revised form 4 February 2016 Accepted 11 February 2016 Available online xxxx We present a computational method that exploits points of interest (POIs) to generate realistic virtual pedestrians for a city model, i.e., a simulated crowd. Our method is validated using mobility traces collected longitudinally from a city-wide free and open Wi-Fi net...
متن کاملMapping Community Engagement with Urban Crowd-Sourcing
Cities are highly dynamic entities, with urban elements such as businesses, cultural and social Points-ofInterests (POIs), housing, transportation and the like, continuously changing. In order to maintain accurate spatial information in these settings, crowd-sourcing models of data collection, such as in OpenStreetMap (OSM), have come under investigation. Like many crowd-sourcing platforms (e.g...
متن کاملIntegrating OpenStreetMap with Google Street View using image processing and machine learning
OpenStreetMap is rapidly expanding crowd-sourced data base of world map. This data, if integrated with visual information from Google Street View would be an immense store of information without manual crowd collection. This paper proposes a method of probabilistically evaluating values of heading or camera angle of Google Street View which points directly to the entity of interest whose latitu...
متن کاملUnderstanding the activity of contributors to VGI projects. How, why, where, and when do they contribute geographic information?
The crowdsourced collection of geographic information (Volunteered Geographic Information VGI) has moved to the center of the research agenda in Web technologies and GIS. Much of the current VGI research is tightly coupled with issues related to the quality of the collected geodata and possible conflation or comparison with other official sources of geodata. This paper presents research which a...
متن کامل